Album Review
Dirty Projectors, David Longstreth & s t a r g a z e - Song Of The Earth
3 StarsWhat it can’t be faulted for is a lack of ambition.
At first glance, the decision to credit this release to both David Longstreth and Dirty Projectors seems redundant, being that he is the only permanent member of that band, which itself started out as a vehicle for his own songwriting. Had there been no mention of Dirty Projectors, though, you wouldn’t have made it ten minutes into ‘Song of the Earth’ without heading to Google to check if this was actually the same David Longstreth. This wild, sprawling 24-track suite is way out of his traditional wheelhouse, an epic song cycle in collaboration with orchestral collective s t a r g a z e that suggests an all-or-nothing approach to stepping outside of his comfort zone; here, he has taken a left turn at 100 miles per hour.
Over the course of more than sixty minutes, we get jazzy orchestral improvisations (‘At Home’), baroque pop (‘Opposable Thumb’), atmospheric laments (‘More Mania’, ‘Spiderweb at Water’s Edge’), off-kilter, groove-driven anthems (‘Uninhabitable Earth, Part One’) and occasional moments of shimmering beauty that seem to stand alone, particularly the Mount Eerie collaboration ‘Twin Aspens’. Emboldened by the sweep of the strings and the portent of the brass that s t a r g a z e provide, Longstreth is similarly ambitious when it comes to thematic content, touching upon everything from climate crisis to Gaia consciousness. It is a heady and often confounding listen and, for many, will be too drastic a departure from his normal territory, or too diffuse and hectic a set of ideas. What ‘Song of the Earth’ can’t be faulted for, though, is a lack of ambition.
Latest Reviews

Olivia Rodrigo - you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love
5 Stars
An accessible yet hugely intelligent album that ushers her into her rightful position as one of her generation’s best artists.
12th June 2026

La Sécurité - Bingo!
3-5 Stars
A breakneck full-length that remains mostly at a blisteringly relentless pace throughout its 10-track tirade.
12th June 2026

The Bobby Lees - New Self
4 Stars
Some prime short, sharp catharsis.
12th June 2026

Tooth - Restless In Bloom
4 Stars
A powerful debut that boasts the promise of exciting things to come.
12th June 2026
More like this
Dirty Projectors release new single ‘Overlord’
It’s the first new material with their current lineup.
27th February 2020
Dirty Projectors - Lamp Lit Prose
4 Stars
Buoyant and witty, and notably shy of meandering eight-minute odysseys.
13th July 2018
Dirty Projectors release new track ‘That’s A Lifestyle’
The band’s new album ‘Lamp Lit Prose’ is out next month.
14th June 2018
Dirty Projectors announce new album ft Haim, Rostam, Robin Pecknold (Fleet Foxes) and more
The record’s first single ‘Break-Thru’ is streaming now.
2nd May 2018
Featuring Yard Act, Death Cab For Cutie, Graham Coxon, Maisie Peters and more.



