EP Review

Alice Costelloe - When It’s The Time

Fizzing with nostalgic warmth.

Alice Costelloe - When It’s The Time

Continuing her musical reintroduction, Alice Costelloe - now releasing under her full name, after one too many queries as to whether the ‘Al’ diminutive she’d been using was in fact ‘A.I.’ - builds on the soft, sweet indie pop of last year’s ‘So Neurotic’ with a second EP, this time making use of the synth menagerie of producer Mike Lindsay. Centring on Alice’s delicate-yet-deliberate vocal once again, ‘When It’s The Time’ sees her dip in and out of an electronic palette – the surprisingly bassy line of the title track, the pep of ‘I Never Dance’ – while keeping focus on where her strength lies: providing a contemporary take on the kind of indie pop the ‘90s made a name for. ‘My Whole Life’ is every bit as wistful musically as its lyrics tell, while the best in show is ‘If I Decide’, fizzing with nostalgic warmth.

Tags: EP Reviews, Neu, Reviews, Alice Costelloe, Moshi Moshi

Latest Reviews

More like this

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

Stay Updated!

Get the best of DIY to your inbox each week.

Latest Issue

May 2026

Festival special! Featuring Wolf Alice, Kasabian, Lykke Li, Marmozets, Genesis Owusu and more.

Read Now Buy Now Subscribe to DIY