With their 2012 emergence, The Neighbourhood sported black-as-tar, film noir imagery, chock-full of Alfred Hitchcock odes. Turns out they’ve stayed true to the cinema-bred darkness, ‘I Love You’ having one of the most misleading album titles of all time.
When frontman Jesse Rutherford spits lines like ‘it hurts but I won’t fight you / you suck anyway,’ you can sure as hell bet he’s not reciting his wedding vows. The album closes with a track called ‘A Little Death’. Just a little. If this is Hitchcock, it’s that scene from Psycho on a gruesome loop, with nothing but jarring static in the background.
Aligning all this hate and melodrama is a ridiculously glossy sheen. It’s a little like the gleaming white-toothed smile we so associate with Los Angeles, as it gleefully distracts from its troublesome undercurrent. Come to California, we’ve got the girls, the sea and the high crime rate. It’s a smarter beast than it gives off, this. Its thick, heavy-going entirety might grate, but songs like ‘Sweater Weather’ are hard-to-tame pop juggernauts.
And even with a title like ‘Everybody’s Watching Me’ drawing attention to the weight of expectation in the album’s mid-section, potential pressure isn’t evident on these young shoulders. They stick to the remarkably fully-formed mantra they arrived on the scene chanting. And while they could go darker, grizzlier, or even shinier, ‘I Love You’ achieves what few debuts can, by making one hell of an opening statement.
Latest Reviews

Graham Coxon - Castle Park
4 Stars
It’s a rare delight to hear him back in the driving seat.
17th June 2026

POND - Terrestrials
4 Stars
They boil everything down to its very essence.
17th June 2026

Swim Deep - Hum
3-5 Stars
A delightful and timely reset pressed.
17th June 2026

LIFE - ABSTRACT / NATURAL
3 Stars
It’ll take the record’s context to prevent it from being that bit too confusing.
17th June 2026
More like this
The Neighbourhood share star-studded ‘Stargazing’ video
Featuring Lana Del Rey, Mac DeMarco, Jaden Smith and more!
14th December 2020
KennyHoopla teams up with The Neighbourhood’s Jesse Rutherford for ‘lost cause//’ reworking
The two trailblazers team up for the sizzling new version.
14th October 2020

The Neighbourhood & Kula Shaker added to AMA Music Festival
They’ll join Foals and Thee Oh Sees at the Italian weekender.
10th May 2016
The Neighbourhood announce UK tour for 2016
Hot off the heels of ‘Wiped Out!’, they’re hitting up the UK once more.
17th November 2015
Featuring Yard Act, Death Cab For Cutie, Graham Coxon, Maisie Peters and more.






