Album Review
Big Thief - Masterpiece
4 StarsWith Adrianne Lenker at the helm, Big Thief can count themselves as emotionally destructive as Sharon Van Etten.
Brooklyn’s Big Thief aren’t a humble bunch, if ‘Masterpiece’’s title is anything to go by. But don’t be fooled. Led by Adrianne Lenker, they claim that love, life and everything in between - that’s the masterpiece, not their snazzy musicianship. Although they’re also adept at the latter, so if they dubbed the next record ‘Greatest Hits’, they might get away with it.
Lenker has a sorrowful voice that lends itself to reverb-lined, dusky songwriting - the kind racing through this record. It’s just as capable firing truths on the epic ‘Real Love’ as it is soundtracking intimacy on opener and home recording, ‘Little Arrow’. When at her best, Lenker can count herself as emotionally destructive as Sharon Van Etten and Bon Iver. In simpler terms - when ‘Masterpiece’ works its magic, you’ll be in bits.
‘Real Love’ is the record’s actual masterpiece. Crazed guitar lines explode like they’re being unshackled, while Lenker covers the vast territory of love and loss without being overbearing. It’s a tough act to follow. ‘Interstate’ tackles the open road, while ‘Paul’ is a tear-soaked tribute to rival the best of them. ‘Animals’’ choppy experimentation meanders, however, and ‘Velvet Ring’ finds Buck Reek’s guitar work tripping into predictable territory.
These are tiny gripes for a record that, beyond anything, announces Big Thief’s name in lights. This is an emotional juggernaut - an avalanche, in fact. Just when they look to have delivered their parting blow, in steps another moment that captures life’s ups and downs with perfection. Expect this to be the start of a huge career, even if this really is their ‘Masterpiece’.
Latest Reviews

Kurt Vile - Philadelphia’s been good to me
4 Stars
A love letter to his hometown that both aches with nostalgia and swells with affection.
27th May 2026

Bleachers - everyone for ten minutes
4 Stars
A display of the magic that can happen when people come together to write songs.
22nd May 2026

Marmozets - CO.WAR.DICE
4-5 Stars
A ferocious return to the forefront.
20th May 2026

Ecca Vandal - Looking For People To Unfollow
3-5 Stars
A varied collection that exhibits Ecca Vandal as a truly exciting rock act.
20th May 2026
More like this

Big Thief conjure spellbinding, eclectic end to four-night Brixton Academy residency
The cult heroes are impossible to pin down, and all the better for it.
27th April 2026

Buck Meek - The Mirror
4-5 Stars
A wonderfully rich collection, this is a record that’s easy to love.
25th February 2026

Buck Meek shares details of poignant new album ‘The Mirror’
It features a range of collaborators, including his brother and Big Thief bandmates.
7th January 2026

Big Thief: Cosmic Dancers
Since 2022’s ‘Dragon New Warm Mountain I Believe In You’, Big Thief have contracted and expanded, breathing new life into their ever-animate body of work. Turning their gaze outwards as a means to make sense of our innermost workings, the now-trio are back bearing cosmically-inclined sixth album ‘Double Infinity’ — their most distilled, disarming record to date.
15th September 2025
Festival special! Featuring Wolf Alice, Kasabian, Lykke Li, Marmozets, Genesis Owusu and more.




