More than a Petty dispute
Tom Petty’s been given a songwriting credit for Sam Smith’s ‘Stay With Me’
Similarities between the song and ‘I Won’t Back Down’ are too clear to ignore, by law.
The resemblances between Sam Smith’s ‘Stay With Me’ and Tom Petty’s ‘I Won’t Back Down’ have now been noted by law.
Initially, when the track came out in April last year, fans picked up on the similarities between Smith’s chart-topping ballad and Petty’s 1989 classic - according to The Sun, a case was settled out of court in October last year. As reported by Consequence of Sound, Petty and co-composer Jeff Lynne have been given a 12.5% writing credit. Other songwriters include Jimmy Napes and Will Philips aka Tourist.
“After it was pointed out to Sam’s camp, they didn’t try to fight it and amicably dished out royalties. It wasn’t a deliberate thing, musicians are just inspired by other artists and Sam and his team were quick to hold up their hand when it was officially flagged,” a source told the newspaper.
This isn’t the only legal issue to hit team Sam Smith of late - he’s been embroiled in a songwriting lawsuit where Disclosure are accused of stealing lyrics, including for ‘Latch’.
Listen to both Petty and Smith’s tracks below.
Update: A representative for Sam Smith has told Rolling Stone the likeness between these two songs is “a complete coincidence”.
Records, etc at

Tom Petty and The Heartbreakers - You're Gonna Get It!
Tom Petty and The Heartbreakers - Long After Dark (Deluxe Edition)
Tom Petty and The Heartbreakers - The Live Anthology - From The Vaults Vol. 1 - RSD Black Friday 2025
Sam Smith - In the Lonely Hour
Sam Smith - Gloria
Sam Smith - In the Lonely Hour - Drowning Shadows Edition
More like this
Loyle Carner, Sam Smith and Michael Kiwanuka among next names for Open’er 2024
Ice Spice and 21 Savage have also just been announced for the Polish festival’s next instalment.
19th December 2023
Sam Smith, Stormzy, Fontaines DC and more to play Sziget Festival 2024
The Island of Freedom have shared the first 35 names confirmed for next year’s knees up in Hungary.
12th December 2023
Charli XCX and Sam Smith collab on new track ‘In The City’
It’s a standalone single that’s been premiered as Radio 1’s Hottest Record.
19th October 2023
Sam Smith reigns supreme on second day of Mad Cool 2023
Queens of the Stone Age also offered up a hefty slab of their brooding rock at the Madrid weekender.
8th July 2023
Featuring Yard Act, Death Cab For Cutie, Graham Coxon, Maisie Peters and more.




