Album Review
Maisie Peters - You Signed Up For This
3-5 StarsBig emotions, small glances, everything feeling life-defining.
It’s hard to believe this is only Maisie Peters’ debut.A regular on radio and playlists for some time, she’s a recent chart-botherer with friends in high places after signing with Ed Sheeran’s Gingerbread Man imprint. And truth be told, there probably couldn’t be a better time to release a collection of heart-on-sleeve songs where the protagonist doesn’t always get the love interest.
Single ‘John Hughes Movie’ sounds as devastatingly catchy here as it does on the airwaves, an empowering heartbreak anthem that’s sure to endure. ‘I’m Trying (Not Friends)’ is full of one-two punches, a biting sense of humour (“You’re seeing someone pretty and I hate her guts / so I’ll be telling you she’s nice on the bus home”) and a relentless chorus. Similarly, Ed Sheeran co-write ‘Psycho’ is refreshingly bold, with Maisie in total pop mode, all layered synths and drum machines making it endlessly replayable. Occasionally, though, when other big pop moments threaten, she lets them fall to the wayside in favour of wordy lyrics, making it feel like a trick has been missed. ‘You Signed Up For This’ is an album about young heartbreak and missed opportunities, smiling because you feel like you should. Big emotions, small glances, everything feeling life-defining. In a world where musicians can feel pressured to release albums year after year, Maisie took her time with this one, resulting in an album that could well be timeless.
Latest Reviews

Olivia Rodrigo - you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love
5 Stars
An accessible yet hugely intelligent album that ushers her into her rightful position as one of her generation’s best artists.
12th June 2026

Paul McCartney - The Boys Of Dungeon Lane
4 Stars
A definitive late-career high point.
29th May 2026

Kurt Vile - Philadelphia’s been good to me
4 Stars
A love letter to his hometown that both aches with nostalgia and swells with affection.
27th May 2026

Bleachers - everyone for ten minutes
4 Stars
A display of the magic that can happen when people come together to write songs.
22nd May 2026
More like this

Yard Act are the cover stars of DIY’s June 2026 issue!
Our latest print mag also features chats with Graham Coxon, Death Cab For Cutie, Maisie Peters, BIG SPECIAL and loads more.
10th June 2026

Maisie Peters: Seasons Change
After a series of high profile support slots and live shows around the effervescent pop of last LP ‘The Good Witch’, Maisie Peters found herself ready for a gear change. With her third album ‘Florescence’, she’s dug a little deeper and found contentment in the more intimate moments of life.
3rd June 2026

Maisie Peters teams up with Julia Michaels for latest album preview ‘Kingmaker’
Loosely inspired by Wolf Hall, it’s about “the sting of uplifting someone, only to find out they didn’t deserve you in the first place.”
22nd April 2026
Reading & Leeds unveil 60+ new names for 2026 lineup
Declan McKenna, Maisie Peters, Holly Humberstone and more are all joining the fun this August.
27th March 2026
Featuring Yard Act, Death Cab For Cutie, Graham Coxon, Maisie Peters and more.




