EP Review
Lucy Dacus - 2019
3 StarsA release that is there to keep the wheels turning ahead of a new album.
After releasing both breakthrough album ‘Historian’ and being part of one third of indie titans Boygenius, it’s safe to say that Lucy Dacus had a strong 2018. In 2019 she has been spontaneously recording songs themed around national holidays and notable events to herself - including, among small things like Christmas, the major event of Bruce Springsteen’s birthday.
The Boss’ big one is marked with a pleasant but overly-faithful cover of ‘Dancing In The Dark — Lucy is a pleasing addition to the list of artists along the road that have covered the track, but it can’t help but fees like a missed opportunity to have added her own brand of magic to it.
Her slow-burn rendition of Phil Collins’ ‘In The Air Tonight’ fares better, her voice adding a dreamlike texture in place of Collins nasal delivery. ‘Last Christmas’ is the most divergent of the covers, adding a punk blast to Wham!’s original that manages to be both charming and bratty: it’s a fine twist to the track and is bound to make Nans worldwide lose their collective shit at the table come December 25th.
The original tracks here are the true standouts: ‘Forever Half Mast’ is a gorgeous country-indebted take about Lucy’s begrudging acceptance of America, erupting into a beautifully fuzzy conclusion. ‘My Mother & I’ is the most beautiful and thoughtful track on the EP, a heartfelt exploration of Lucy’s relationship with her parent built around cascading guitars and lovely harmonies - it’s one of the strongest tracks she’s put to tape.
‘2019’ has a pleasing feel no doubt, there are some gems nestled in the 7-track run that are well worth a look, but it feels like a release that is there to keep the wheels turning ahead of a new album.
Latest Reviews

Kurt Vile - Philadelphia’s been good to me
4 Stars
A love letter to his hometown that both aches with nostalgia and swells with affection.
27th May 2026

Bleachers - everyone for ten minutes
4 Stars
A display of the magic that can happen when people come together to write songs.
22nd May 2026

Marmozets - CO.WAR.DICE
4-5 Stars
A ferocious return to the forefront.
20th May 2026

Ecca Vandal - Looking For People To Unfollow
3-5 Stars
A varied collection that exhibits Ecca Vandal as a truly exciting rock act.
20th May 2026
More like this

Lucy Dacus drops new Record Store Day single ‘Planting Tomatoes’
Its charmingly DIY lyric video was filmed in a Tokyo stationery shop.
24th April 2026

Lucy Dacus surprise releases double A-side ‘Bus Back To Richmond’ / ‘More Than Friends’
The pair of tracks follow her latest solo album, ‘Forever Is A Feeling’, which came out earlier this year.
8th August 2025

Lucy Dacus: True Romance
Fresh from dominating the music world as one third of boygenius — and gaining legions of new fans in the process — Lucy Dacus is back with her most intimate and vulnerable solo record to date.
30th April 2025

Djo is the cover star of DIY’s April 2025 issue!
Our latest edition also features chats with Lucy Dacus, Sunflower Bean, Black Country, New Road and loads more.
8th April 2025
Festival special! Featuring Wolf Alice, Kasabian, Lykke Li, Marmozets, Genesis Owusu and more.





