EP Review
Penelope Scott - Girl’s Night / Mysteries For Rats
4-5 StarsHer densely packed, stream-of-consciousness writing style knits it all together.
There’s a logical reasoning for ‘Mysteries for Rats’ and ‘Girl’s Night’ arriving as two separate but simultaneous EPs rather than one full album. The former, a largely electronic selection (in the most lo-fi, bedroom synth way); the latter based in guitars and piano, there’s a fairly neat sonic split down the middle. What that doesn’t account for, however, is the totally inimitable voice, pacing and witty lyrical style of Penelope Scott herself. Whether she’s evoking pissed-off vaudevillian high drama on ‘Cabaret’, hyperpop-adjacent romantic malaise on ‘Gross’, or Moldy Peaches-esque, rough-around-the-edges folk on ‘Pseudophed’, Scott’s densely packed, stream-of-consciousness writing style knits it all together regardless.
The aforementioned ‘Cabaret’ is the collection’s meta centrepiece: a dissection of a clearly-unwanted comment on her music, spun out into an increasingly fraught conversation with herself (“My shit all sounds the same to you, I bet it fucking does…”). We’d take that sentiment and switch it up; Penelope Scott’s shit sounds like herself and literally nothing else around right now - and that’s a glorious thing.
Latest Reviews

Olivia Rodrigo - you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love
5 Stars
An accessible yet hugely intelligent album that ushers her into her rightful position as one of her generation’s best artists.
12th June 2026

Paul McCartney - The Boys Of Dungeon Lane
4 Stars
A definitive late-career high point.
29th May 2026

Kurt Vile - Philadelphia’s been good to me
4 Stars
A love letter to his hometown that both aches with nostalgia and swells with affection.
27th May 2026

Bleachers - everyone for ten minutes
4 Stars
A display of the magic that can happen when people come together to write songs.
22nd May 2026
Featuring Yard Act, Death Cab For Cutie, Graham Coxon, Maisie Peters and more.




