Album review
Car Seat Headrest - The Scholars
4 StarsA psychedelic, classic rock mashup that absorbs and expands on the sound Car Seat Headrest have claimed as their own.
To follow newfound fame among young listeners with an hour-plus rock opera is a bold move to most, but for Virginia born Will Toledo and his expansive Car Seat Headrest project, it doesn’t fall a million miles away from the more epic moments peppered throughout his acclaimed catalogue. Although ‘The Scholars’ embraces the idea of a concept record at its most distilled, Will and friends have never shied away from a fifteen-minute sonic whirlwind. But perhaps most notably here, these friends have been fully absorbed into the fold, expanding in sound from Will’s solo musings for an altogether more composed affair to allow some breathing room for Will – who has spent some of the past five years battling some almost career-ending health issues - and to bring the album’s character-driven narrative to life.
That story, centring around a series of fictional personalities at the equally fictitious Parnassus University, is perhaps arguably difficult to follow, but builds the backdrop for a psychedelic, classic rock mashup that absorbs and expands on the sound Car Seat Headrest have claimed as their own. It also allows for Will to frame his own rebirth of sorts; within its nods to David Bowie, The Who and a whole plethora of celebrated rockers unfurls a complex tale of family, sexuality, poison, and world-saving superpowers. The immediacy of the comparably short and sharp first half (at least in track number alone) gives way to a sprawling crescendo of epics – not least the near-19 minute ‘Planet Desperation’; a track as camp as it is masterful, with more than a gentle nod to the 1960s and ‘70s. This grandeur and scale appears the opposite to the fleeting nature of the online platforms that have introduced Car Seat Headrest to a whole new audience, but then perhaps that’s the point – for Will, his band, and their fans, there really is a new world to explore, quite literally.
Latest Reviews

Graham Coxon - Castle Park
4 Stars
It’s a rare delight to hear him back in the driving seat.
17th June 2026

POND - Terrestrials
4 Stars
They boil everything down to its very essence.
17th June 2026

Swim Deep - Hum
3-5 Stars
A delightful and timely reset pressed.
17th June 2026

LIFE - ABSTRACT / NATURAL
3 Stars
It’ll take the record’s context to prevent it from being that bit too confusing.
17th June 2026
More like this

Car Seat Headrest introduce first album in five years with 11-minute single ‘Gethsemane’
Their new record, ‘The Scholars’, is a concept rock opera set at a fictional university…
6th March 2025
Car Seat Headrest release ‘MADLO: Influences’ and ‘MADLO: Remixes’
The two EPs are streaming now!
22nd June 2021
Car Seat Headrest perform ‘Can’t Cool Me Down’ live on Jimmy Fallon
It’s the band’s first live TV performance since the release of ‘Making A Door Less Open’.
20th November 2020
Odd One Out: Car Seat Headrest
Four years on since mainstream-baiting LP ‘Teens Of Denial’, Will Toledo is back with a banger. But if you thought you knew what to expect from Car Seat Headrest then get ready to make a sharp U‑turn.
5th November 2020
Featuring Yard Act, Death Cab For Cutie, Graham Coxon, Maisie Peters and more.




