Album Review
The Mysterines - Afraid Of Tomorrows
4 StarsIn venturing into the shadows, they’ve made their boldest move yet.
For anyone who thought that - fresh from bagging a Top Ten spot for their 2022 debut - The Mysterines would return with something more immediate, you couldn’t be more wrong. Instead, their second record is a gloriously dingy affair, dwelling in the deepest, darkest crevices of the mind. Much like its title suggests, here, frontwoman Lia Metcalfe sounds like she’s unravelling, with her lyrics diving into the paranoia-tinged corners of anxiety and addiction. Opener ‘The Last Dance’ casts a foreboding shadow on the record from the off, further amped up when a vulnerable yet demented-sounding Lia begins its scratchy, whispered outro (“Unholy kind of accidents / Happen when / The puppet cuts the string”). Elsewhere, ‘Another, Another, Another’ possesses a Placebo-ish swagger, before ‘Tired Animal’ slinks into view, slowly dialling up the album’s tension. It’s not all darkness, though; the acoustic-backed ‘Hawkmoon’ provides a sense of fragile levity (soon exploding into a vivid, full-bodied instrumental), while ‘Sink Ya Teeth’ is as close to a vibrant banger as they’re willing to go. Their closing one-two of ‘So Long’ and ‘Afraid Of Tomorrows’, meanwhile, brings things to a bittersweet but somewhat hopeful close. The quartet may have bucked expectations here, but in venturing into the shadows, they’ve made their boldest move yet.
Latest Reviews

Graham Coxon - Castle Park
4 Stars
It’s a rare delight to hear him back in the driving seat.
17th June 2026

POND - Terrestrials
4 Stars
They boil everything down to its very essence.
17th June 2026

Swim Deep - Hum
3-5 Stars
A delightful and timely reset pressed.
17th June 2026

LIFE - ABSTRACT / NATURAL
3 Stars
It’ll take the record’s context to prevent it from being that bit too confusing.
17th June 2026
More like this
Your New Favourite Bands (…as chosen by your old favourite bands)
Need to give your playlists a summer refresh? We picked the brains of some DIY faves for their best new music recommendations.
28th June 2024
The Mysterines: Facing The Future
While The Mysterines’ debut saw the Liverpool quartet stand out as one of guitar music’s brightest new stars, on follow-up ‘Afraid Of Tomorrows’ they’re embarking on a foreboding but startling new chapter.
28th May 2024
The Mysterines share hedonistic new video for their punchy single ‘Sink Ya Teeth’
It’s the latest track to be lifted from their upcoming second album ‘Afraid of Tomorrows’.
14th May 2024
Rachel Chinouriri is the cover star of DIY’s May 2024 issue!
Our new issue — out now! — also features A.G. Cook, Yannis Philippakis, Wasia Project, The Mysterines and loads more!
9th May 2024
Featuring Yard Act, Death Cab For Cutie, Graham Coxon, Maisie Peters and more.




